Yesterday I got sucked into a Canadian TV series called Being Erica. Erica is a 32-year-old woman who has no job and no man. What she does have is a long list of regrets. Erica believes these past mistakes have caused her present disappointment. She meets an unusual therapist, Dr. Tom, who sends her back in time to do things differently.
One of Erica’s greatest regrets is the death of her brother, Leo. In the season finale, Dr. Tom allows Erica to go back to the day of her brother’s death with the stipulation that she will not do anything to change the outcome of the day. According to Dr. Tom, bringing people back from the dead is one thing his brand of therapy cannot do.
This got me thinking about other narratives that have the same prohibition about bringing people back from the dead. In Aladdin, when the genie is explaining the rules of Aladdin’s three wishes, one rule is that the genie can’t bring anyone back from the dead. I remember reading "The Monkey’s Paw" in middle school in which a couple wishes a dead son brought back to life with horrific consequences.
I can’t think of any story in which someone truly comes back from the dead. I used to watch All My Children with my mom and people came back from the dead (or a failed attempt at a Hollywood career) pretty often. We always found out they hadn’t been dead at all, just living in another town with amnesia.
Dead people coming back to life, at least in a way that isn’t terrifying, is a theme we just don’t see in movies and literature. And yet, the Christian faith rests on the premise that Jesus came back from the dead (and wasn’t scary).
In the Resurrection, God engineered the greatest happy ending ever recorded, but it is an ending that goes against all the rules of storytelling. For some of us, God's refusal to work within the scope of human imagination is a stumbling block. For others, it is a reason to believe.
R-E-S-P-E-C-T
9 years ago
